Marrying Anita

The US had failed her. So Anita Jain turned to her ancestral home to provide a husband.

By Terry Hong  |  August 4, 2008 edition

Marrying Anita: A Quest for Love in the New India By Anita Jain Bloomsbury 307 pp. $24.99

At 32, Anita Jain is an object of pity. Never mind her Harvard degree and a journalism career with its expat adventures in far-flung destinations such as London, Mexico City, and Singapore. Ask any auntie or uncle, and they will most assuredly shake their heads at “Naresh’s daughter who is still unmarried.”

Naresh – said father of the pitiable girl – has regularly been placing matrimonial ads on his daughter’s behalf since her 20s: “They read something like, ‘Match for Jain girl, Harvard-educated journalist, 25, fair, slim.’” (Jain is both the family’s religion and last name.)

Her mother, meanwhile, has been worried since her daughter fell out the window of a three-story building at age 1: “My mother’s greatest concern at the time, after learning that I hadn’t been gravely injured, was my marriageability. ‘What boy will marry her when he finds out?’”

So what’s an accomplished woman to do under such pressure? In Jain’s case, she relocates to the land of her immigrant parents to search for that elusive mate. And, in contemporary full-disclosure fashion, she writes a rollicking memoir: Marrying Anita: A Quest for Love in the New India.

Although the child of a blissfully happy arranged marriage, Jain enjoyed “a rare amount of freedom during [her] twenties to find someone of [her] own choosing.”

Marriage remained the goal: “It would not be a stretch to say that ‘shaadi,’ the word for ‘marriage’ in many Indian languages, is the first word a child in an Indian family understands after mummy and papa. To an Indian, marriage is a matter of karmic destiny.”

Entering her 30s, Jain finds herself in Manhattan, caught up in the nightlife of young professionals, which translates into parties, bars, and forgetful hook-ups. Intimidated by talk of “JDate and booty calls” and other unappealing methods of courtship, Jain eventually succumbs to her father’s Internet dating efforts on her behalf – he not only writes her profile but also screens unsuspecting prospects.

Even as she eschews her father’s updated version of arranged marriage, Jain’s opposition starts to falter: “…after a decade of Juan Carloses, and affairs with married men, and Craigslist flirtations, and emotionally bankrupt boyfriends, and (oddly, the most painful of all) the guys who just never call, [arranged marriage] no longer seemed like the most outlandish possibility.”

India, Jain thinks, holds more options: “I could go in for a strict arranged marriage, an ‘assisted marriage,’ or I could merely date in a pool far more oriented toward marriage than the one I was dealing with in New York City.”

Jain gives herself a year in Delhi to find a husband. In a way, it was a tribute to her parents and their relationship. “[I]t was my father’s own self-taught views on women,” Jain writes, “that had given me hope that I would be able to find a husband in India liberal enough in mind-set and outlook to handle me.”

But the India to which Jain returns in the summer of 2005 is a brave new world that hardly recalls her father’s country of “byzantine tales of indigence.” Twenty-first century India is a behemoth success story filled with booming technology, enviable fashion, world-renowned literature and artists, and ever-present Bollywood glamour.

Setting up her new life is not without hurdles, least of all finding a place to live: After numerous setbacks in finding a flat, Jain comes across a newspaper article which reveals Delhi landlords “suspect young women who can afford a place of their own to be involved in prostitution.”

Jain is nothing if not tenacious, and finally manages to “set up the perfect Indian home by myself in Delhi,” complete with a cook and an insouciant maid who tells her which clothes make her look fat.

Highlights of her year-long mate-search include a long-distance flirtation with a Kashmiri ex-holy man, infatuation with a younger family friend, and initiating a devout Sikh into the joys of kissing.

When her parents come for a six-week visit, her father resorts again to marriage ads – which result in a hopeful online dalliance with a Luxembourg-based consultant and a “livetime” relationship with an IT specialist who studied at her father’s alma mater.

Lest you think Jain’s narrative reads like an amorous laundry list, romance comes with some poignant revelations. Jain journeys to India in search of a husband, yes, but also “a sense of belonging that I haven’t found in the U.S.” Her reverse immigration ironically proves otherwise as she admits: “I look Indian but am not.”

“[My] year in Delhi has thrown me so many curveballs, I should hardly be shocked,” Jain concludes.

“That full-of-possibility, anything-can-happen feel” will eventually cement Jain’s stay. So does she or doesn’t she find true love? No secrets revealed here – just one hint: Skipping to the last page offers no easy answers!

Terry Hong is media arts consultant at the Smithsonian Asian Pacific American Program.

( More stories )

Comments

1. Kaurik Raj | 08.06.08

Very descriptive and with a low ‘gunning fog index’. She paints a vivid picture of places many have not seen. I have been there and know how well Ms. Jain describes things, people, places and customs.

I’ve read this book in a single sitting and I’m sure many other will.

Kaurik

2. Blueprint | 08.07.08

My initial reaction reading this review was ‘had I not seen this movie before!’ So, here’s another story, hardly original, of a self-absorbed child of immigrant parents returning to the country of her ancestors in search of her sould - a husband in this case, and that somehow a mate would make her whole and complete. This would be just the kind of book her American readers will lap up taken in by the exotic locale and characters described within its pages.
With a line like this quoted in the Monitor one should take a great pause before rushing to your local bookstore or library to pick up the book.
“[My] year in Delhi has thrown me so many curveballs, I should hardly be shocked,” Jain concludes.

Hmm! They much prefer Cricket in India!

So let’s put things in perspective, despite all the news of dramatic changes in India, highlighted by the author’s quest for a mate, the vast majority of Indians especially in the countryside and villages have seen little improvement in their lives.
A sobering child-mortality UNICEF report showed – in 2006 India accounted for 2.1 million deaths of children less than five years. Something to chew on! Cheers, SC.

3. Yesh Prabhu, Plainsboro, NJ | 09.04.08

Yes, Anita Jain writes well. There are many witty one-liners and sarcastic two-liners that elicit easy laughs from readers. However, while many Westerners and especially Americans might find the book entertaining and highly readable, many Indians might find it troubling, offensive and painful. I understand that her parents were not happy when they read the book. Because Anita Jain doesn’t know much about Indian culture, social norms, and etiquette, she misinterprets the behavior of some of the prospective suitors and misunderstands their actions. Like a woman afflicted with a severe case of jaundice, to whom everything appears as yellow, her interpretations of Indian men’s behavior, and the conclusions she draws from an American’s perspective, are stilted and distorted. Also, I was shocked to read that while talking to one suitor, she suddenly asks her father to fetch her a glass of water, and the father dutifully complies. An Indian daughter, or a daughter who knows Indian culture, would never ask her father to fetch her a glass of water. I also felt pain when I read some of the needlessly snide remarks she made about the men she met, remarks made only to elicit easy laughter from the readers. I think only very few (if any at all) men will be drawn to such capricious and disdainful behavior. Most sane men are likely to run away. A little humility will go a long way in winning over human hearts.

4. haroon marikar | 09.09.08

hmmmm
read the book ,the comments too :)
This girl anita jain has written from her perspective which is neither indian nor american but truly of a non-resident indian . her views may not agree with our hypocritical culture .

the average indian man cannot digest the sleep around culture, women drinking etc described in the book but right or wrong this culture is catching up in the metroes and she just observed it and written about it unnerving to many but truth can be bitter and times are changing

I liked her language and honesty very much —and thats my opinion :)
haroon marikar

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

Leave a Comment

  By clicking "Submit Comment", you agree to our Terms of Service.

We do not publish all comments, and we do not publish comments immediately. The comments feature is a forum to discuss the ideas in our stories. Constructive debate - even pointed disagreement - is welcome, but personal attacks on other commenters are not, and will not be published.

Tip: Do not write a novel. Keep it short. We will not publish lengthy comments. Come up with your own statements. This is not a place to cut and paste an email you received. If we recognize it as such, we won't post it.

Please do not post any comments that are commercial in nature or that violate copyrights.

Finally, we will not publish any comments that we regard as obscene, defamatory, or intended to incite violence.