Harry Potter film No. 6: How true to the book?
By Marjorie Kehe | 07.13.09
Fans have had to wait an extra eight months for its release (due to a delay, “Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince,” set to debut this Wednesday, July 15, was originally scheduled to hit theaters last November) and so there’s been that much more time to wonder.
How much will Harry Potter film No. 6 resemble the J.K. Rowling book from which it comes?
It has been more than 10 years since the first Harry Potter book was released in the United States, and that means that there’s now a whole generation of 20-something readers who literally grew up with the books. So perhaps it’s not surprising that much of the speculation over the film is taking place on the blogs of college students.
On DNOnline (the Ball State University online news daily), Aly Brumback interviews students planning to attend that first midnight showing. Senior photojournalism major Cassandra Adamson predicts film No. 6 will be darker than the earlier films. And that’s a good thing, says Adamson.
“I think the movies are getting better and better each time around. As they get darker, they’re getting better,” she told Brumback.
But Adamson sees the movies changing along with the books.
Holly Pierson, writing for The Exponent, Purdue University’s daily student newspaper, also says the films are getting darker and better – but she sees them moving further away from the books. And she thinks that’s a good thing.
Pierson says she began to lose her enthusiasm for the books after No. 4 (”Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire“), but in her opinion the films are getting richer as they move away from the books. “It’s harder to write endings than beginnings, I’ll give [J.K. Rowling] that,” she writes. “But when Rowlings upped the angst and started churning out more pages than plot with each successive book, I began to doubt her early claims that she knew where the series was headed from the beginning.”
“On the other hand,” she opines, “the movies have only been getting better.”
If you want to see a point-by-point analysis of the ways in which the movie version of “Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince” will differ from the book, take a look at today’s New York Post. Or you can just wait and see for yourself.
Comments
2. Anna | 07.13.09
I loved the books and personally hope that the movies come as close as they possibly can to them. MOst everyone that i have talked to said that they loved the first movie the most, is it a coincidence that THAT particular movie was the closest to the books?? I dont think so…
3. Lee | 07.13.09
I think it’s great when the books are as close to the movie as possible, but also think that they have to have freedom to interpret the books into the movie format. It didn’t bother me that the books were long–it gave more time with Harry, Hermione, and Ron!
4. HP | 07.13.09
There have to be some room left for filmmakers so that they can show their interpretation of the book. The film should give great feeling for both, who read books and those who not. Let’s see.. it’s so close!
5. Andrew | 07.14.09
I very much liked reading the earlier books to my kids and I am glad that Harry Potter still fascinates so many people. Now that is what I call an effective spell!
6. Annie | 07.29.09
I don’t know where the positive critical claim for this movie stems from, aside from the look it was downright awful. It’s as if the filmmakers slapped the 5th movie in the face and ignored all the good things it achieved. I want my money back. I found a good rant that gets to the bottom of it here: http://www.pandalous.com/topic/harry_potter_6
Trackbacks/Pingbacks
Leave a Comment
We do not publish all comments, and we do not publish comments immediately. The comments feature is a forum to discuss the ideas in our stories. Constructive debate - even pointed disagreement - is welcome, but personal attacks on other commenters are not, and will not be published.
Tip: Do not write a novel. Keep it short. We will not publish lengthy comments. Come up with your own statements. This is not a place to cut and paste an email you received. If we recognize it as such, we won't post it.
Please do not post any comments that are commercial in nature or that violate copyrights.
Finally, we will not publish any comments that we regard as obscene, defamatory, or intended to incite violence.
1. NATHAN | 07.13.09
i think the books where good, and the films should be as equal as possible in my oppinion.