Can you hear this? Didn't think so. (Toyota)
Are hybrids too quiet?
By Eoin O'Carroll | 05.29.08
Now that there are at least one million Priuses on the road, along with many other gas-electric hybrid vehicles, people are becoming concerned that the eco-friendly cars are not so friendly to the blind.
When traveling below 25 miles per hour, a Prius runs silently on electric power. While some may welcome the reduction in traffic noise, the cars make it difficult for pedestrians – particularly those who can’t see – to know when they’re approaching.
In April, Representatives Ed Towns (D-NY) and Cliff Stearns (R-FL) introduced the Pedestrian Safety Enhancement Act of 2008, which would require the Department of Transportation to establish minimum sound levels for all hybrid and electric vehicles.
This bill is heartily endorsed by The National Federation for the Blind:
“The National Federation of the Blind appreciates the wise and decisive action taken today by Congressmen Towns and Stearns to preserve the right to safe and independent travel for the blind,” said Dr. Marc Maurer, President of the National Federation of the Blind. “The blind, like all pedestrians, must be able to travel to work, to school, to church, and to other places in our communities without being injured or killed. This bill will benefit all pedestrians for generations to come as new vehicle technologies become more prevalent. The blind of America will do everything in our power to ensure its swift passage.”
Some Prius owners aren’t thrilled at the prospect of having their cars’ volume increased. In some online forums, the bill has been labeled the “Bell the Hybrid Act.”
But if the bill passes, it will raise some questions:How would the cars make the noise? And what noise would they make?
Two grad students at Stanford have come up with an answer.
Everett Meyer, a med student, and Bryan Bai, an engineering student, came up with a system that emits sounds from palm-sized speakers placed under the front wheel wells and the back bumper. According to a press release from Stanford, their PANDA system (that’s Pedestrian Awareness Noise-emitting Device and Application) is about 5 decibels quieter than a regular combustion engine from the front and 10 to 20 decibels quieter from the back. The noise is not audible from inside the car, unless you roll down the windows.
The press release described the sound as unlike a car engine, but rather “a bit closer to a muted jet engine, with some static and white noise thrown in.”
Meyer and Bai have started a company called Enhanced Vehicle Acoustics.
It all sounds like a great idea, but somebody should have told them that a similar, cheaper device has already been invented.
<< Group sends bamboo homes to China’s quake zone | MainComments
2. ST | 05.30.08
When the car was first invented in the 19th century they were not allowed to go faster than a person walking, and someone had to walk in front of them waving a red flag. Why not try that, and hey we can have the flag beep I guess for the blind.
This is one of the weirdest urban legend stories that goes round and round I have ever encountered. Nothing like solving problems where none exist. Patently weird. Should we put bells on our shoes, our bikes, our strollers? The tire noise of a Prius alone is enough, it composes half the sound of a vehicle.
3. ST | 05.30.08
I remember when the EV1 came out, there was a massive wave of ‘reports’ of the batteries exploding. It was enough to kill the whole project. Turns out they misinformation was created by the US car industry to try kill the EV1. The battery exploding meme worked.
I suspect there is a black flag in this ‘news’ meme as well. Cars unsafe for the blind. Probably unsafe for kittens and babies as well wouldn’t you say?
4. Scot | 05.30.08
No restrictions on the height and instability of SUV’s though. Their high center of gravity and lack of ability to even SEE a pedestrian was NEVER an issue. The problem of them backing over people, running over people and rolling over killing the occupants I guess was not a problem - to GM and Ford.
5. Barbara Santoro | 05.30.08
Considering the baby-boomers are nearing the age of irreversable, unchangeable macular degeneration or sudden blindness, perhaps smart alecs like John Thornton or ST, should reconsider their comments. Nice people.
6. zqahtt | 05.30.08
Is this a joke?How many blind people are jaywalking and/or dashing into traffic?The idiot in control of the vehicle is responsible for control of the vehicle at all times and the onus is on the driver to watch out for anything in their path and for always deferring to pedestrians in front of them sighted or not.
Trackbacks/Pingbacks
Leave a Comment
We do not publish all comments, and we do not publish comments immediately. The comments feature is a forum to discuss the ideas in our stories. Constructive debate - even pointed disagreement - is welcome, but personal attacks on other commenters are not, and will not be published.
Tip: Do not write a novel. Keep it short. We will not publish lengthy comments. Come up with your own statements. This is not a place to cut and paste an email you received. If we recognize it as such, we won't post it.
Please do not post any comments that are commercial in nature or that violate copyrights.
Finally, we will not publish any comments that we regard as obscene, defamatory, or intended to incite violence.
1. John Thornton | 05.29.08
Hello,
The quietness of the Prius and other hybrids is one of their nicest benefits. Instead of putting noise makers on them, how about integrating something into White Canes that detects a nearby moving vehicle and alerts the blind person?
What’s next? Continuous noise makers are bicycles and sneakers?