Bright Green Blog

Bruce Kania aboard one of his mesh-and-foam floating islands, which clean water so that aquatic life can flourish.

(David Grubbs/Billings Gazette/AP)

Photos (1 of 1)

How to clean up a lake? Floating islands might be the answer.

Man-made islands can remove ammonia, heavy metals, and other chemicals from the water.

By Matt Hagengruber  |  Correspondent of The Christian Science Monitor/ May 20, 2009 edition

SHEPHERD, MONT.

Bruce Kania built his large home atop a bluff with an expansive view of the Yellowstone River, which flows past on its 670-mile journey from Yellowstone National Park to its confluence with the Missouri River.

Mr. Kania moved here a decade ago to enjoy the natural setting. But he soon began to worry about the surface water draining into the Yellowstone. Kania’s black dog went for a swim one day in a pond on his property, and the dog came out of the water covered in slime.

“You could smell him from 50 feet away,” Kania said.

The experienced inventor got to thinking about water quality. Irrigation ditches divert clean water from the Yellowstone. The ditches feed pastures and fields, and what is left drains back into the river. Beef cattle roam the land. In the nearby town of Shepherd, a giant feedlot produced tons of manure every day.

Where some saw pollution, Kania saw nutrients.

“It became apparent that this represented a terrific opportunity for somebody,” he said. “What can be done with those nutrients?”

The answer is floating bio-islands.

In his college days, Kania had been a fishing guide in northern Wisconsin. There, he saw giant natural floating islands that had grown over generations, big enough to support trees. These areas had huge muskellunge, prized sport fish, and Kania thought the islands were one reason. They scrubbed the water clean and provided the forage that grew big fish.

In Montana, Kania decided to produce man-made floating islands that could do the same. They’re constructed of layers of mesh and insulating foam. The mesh feels like the rough side of a sponge: The bigger islands are buoyant enough to hold people.

Most are at least 25 square feet, and the least expensive costs around $600. They’re topped with soil and seeds and then launched in lakes and ponds. The islands act like magnets for microbes, and the seeds sprout into vegetation that pulls nitrogen, phosphorus, and other nutrients that cause slime from the surrounding water, cleaning it and allowing aquatic life to flourish.

Kania shows off pictures of giant perch that his employees have caught in test ponds on his property. The perch’s bellies were full of snails, which Kania thinks consume the vegetation growing from the islands, which he calls “floating supermarkets.”

Kania, a tall, bearded man who moved to Montana in 1976, has turned his invention into a business called Floating Islands International. He has about a half-dozen employees and is now licensing the islands to companies that will make them full time.

That leaves time for Kania to get back to inventing. “Our license holders do the hard work of manufacturing,” he says. “We do the fun work of invention.”

The mesh for the islands is made from recycled plastic bottles and comes in wide black rolls. Each island consists of several layers, which are stacked before a worker shoots expanding foam between the layers. When the foam dries, the layers are locked together.

Holes are cut into the mesh and filled with plants. Grasses and flowers grow above the water, while their roots grow down through the mesh and into the water. Insects and minnows hide and forage in the roots underneath the islands, and bigger fish are attracted to the smaller fish. The islands expand over time.

The floating islands allow water to circulate, and they provide surface area for nutrient-hungry microbes, which form a film that is loosely connected to the islands. As the plants use more nitrogen and phosphorus to grow, there is less available in the water for algae blooms, which give off an unpleasant odor and form a suffocating shadow on top of the water.

“We’re taking a big enough bite out of the nutrient load that we’re not getting algae,” says Damien Austin, Kania’s staff biologist.

Evidence is mounting that the islands can remove ammonia, heavy metals, and other chemicals from the water, too. They act as a sponge on a wet countertop: Water is drawn in, and the bad stuff sticks. “It looks like a good idea, and I’m kind of surprised no one else has thought of this before, at least in a marketable way,” says Joe Gathman, a biology professor at the University of Wisconsin at River Falls.

“Ideally, problems like [excess nutrients] should be stopped at their source: Mop it up before it gets into the lake. But these islands could be helpful little mops,” he says.

The main office for Floating Islands International is just a few feet from Kania’s house. A shop and laboratory are a mile down a dirt road. Twice a week, Kania and his staff – which includes his wife, Anne – meet for lunch at the Feedlot Steakhouse outside Shepherd. They talk floating islands, from buoyancy calculations to which type of soil works best.

Floating islands are being used from downtown Chicago to Singapore. In Billings, Mont., a city of 100,000, city engineers are using floating islands to filter storm water. The local zoo uses an island in its otter habitat and no longer has to chemically treat the water, says Tim Mulholland, an engineer and one of eight license-holders who build the islands.

Kania’s licensees recently built a 22,000-square-foot island for the US Army Corps of Engineers, which launched it in a lake in Oregon. The island provides habitat for the Caspian tern. The shore birds are being relocated away from the Columbia River estuary, where they eat 5 million salmon fry a year.

“It’s floating great,” says Kitia Chambers, an Army Corps engineer. “We’ll definitely monitor this one, and if all goes well, we’d like to use this design again.”

Ideally, the licenses will fund other inventions. Kania is planning to launch an island this summer with a wind turbine on it, and he’s trying shredded carpet in the islands.

“We’re not a marketing company, and we’re not a manufacturing company,” he says. “My job as CEO is to maintain the perspective of an inventor.”

( More stories )

Comments

1. BB | 05.20.09

What a simple and elegent solution to such a big problem. This is what innovation looks like.

2. Jim Birdsall | 05.20.09

“… Kania is planning to launch an island this summer with a wind turbine on it…” In addition to generating electricity, the turbine could pump air down to depths that are oxygen deficient. JimB

3. Tim | 05.20.09

W-o-o-p!!

4. JoeReal | 05.20.09

You can google for SolarBee and it should come up with plenty of hits. It should be able to take care of problems like the one above, in a much better way, without having to float a lot more garbage in the pond or lake.

5. JimL | 05.21.09

I disagree with the previous comment about SolarBee being a better solution to problems with excess nutrients in lakes and ponds. The floating islands are not trash or garbage. They are recycled materials that keep trash out of landfills. They provide extra habitat for various organisms. The idea of putting floating wind turbines on these islands is excellent. Perhaps combining the floating islands and the SolarBee technology would provide a beneficial synergy as well.

6. Clara | 05.23.09

I’m going to contact our local Army Corps of Engineers on this one.

I thank Bruce Kania for his innovative application.

7. visualmerc | 05.24.09

this is the kind of environmental innovation america needs more of. once we realize that we can help natural systems replenish themselves and even integrate different types of systems together, we’ll be able gain ground on the war against pollution. kudos to mr. kania.

8. Leo | 05.28.09

The Problem with these “islands” is that they are at best a short term solution without massive amounts of maintenance. Natural floating islands are actually a type of wetland with a well developed food chain that processes the plant material after it dies, reinforcing the island structure, providing energy and nutrients to the microbial community and channeling some benefits to the fish and waterbirds. An artificial island will need to be maintained regularly to remove the plant material to prevent overgrowth and failure. Removing nutrients, metals or other contaminants through the removal of plant material is extremely inefficient as the plants are typically 95% or more water by weight and far less than 1% contaminant. The islands may provide a short term solution in small ponds with limited loading (like the zoo example) but are ineffective otherwise. Additionally this is a VERY old concept in water quality management that is simply seeing a return by an inventor who thinks he has insight that has been missing in the past, his licensees would be well served by reviewing the lake management literature addressing this approach from the past.

9. James Stepp | 05.28.09

A new take on an old and very good idea. The American Indians living in Mexico City did the same thing using trees and are credited with inventing the first forms of hydroponics.

Mr. Kania, I wish you all success and if you happen to read this you may want to check out how they did it for fresh (not!) ideas on ways to use it. They managed to grow massive amounts of food on that lake, among other things. Their islands had houses on them and easily carry families of people. Using natural materials could also lower your cost, increasing your bottom line.

10. Rob N | 06.08.09

Great for nutrients, but does the island soak up all the metals and other bad toxins? The potential pitfall is that all the microbes, snails, etc, will bio-accumulate and pass on accumlated bad-stuff to larger animals such as birds that nest and feed on islands and fish that feed on islands.
Recycled plastic as islands? Can anyone say bisphenol leachate?

The islands sound like a good short-term, temporary tool, that will allow biologists and managers to clean up the water while working at fixing the source of the nutrients, chemicals.
As the article says, this island is not a replacement for stopping the bad stuff at the source, nor should it be a long-term soloution.

11. jefro | 06.09.09

Wonder how damaging the plastic is to the wildlife when it breaks down? Maybe there is a natural solution?

12. orfej | 06.11.09

“Can anyone say bisphenol leachate?

Actually, no. I don’t think anyone can.

13. anna | 07.05.09

There have been floating islands available for at least 5 years for use in Koi ponds and water gardens. They are not as large but utilize a similar approach and we have successfully used them to maintain the water quality in ponds. In our breeder pond we have a home made one that keeps 37,000 gallons of water clear.
I am glad to see that there will be a commercial application. Not only do they clean the water but provide an environment for wildlife which here in Florida is rapidly shrinking. I have several turtles that call mine home.
Good article

14. Framingham MA Real Estate | 09.15.09

What a fantastic idea! Not only do these islands help the environment but they are also attractive and create a unique place where you can hang out and enjoy the surroundings!

15. michael l. weed | 11.06.09

I’m a 51 yr old man 1st semester in college fir horticulture. Was outside with instructor and class by the college pond and found out it was our job to come up with a landscape around the pond. I got a brainstorm about a floating island or garden. Generally for the same reasons you have listed here. Just didn’t know how to go about it. Saw your website and fell in love with it. can I get one thru you or can you email me directions or what can I do to involve myself with this idea? Any feedback would be greatly appreciated. Thank You, Michael Weed (Great last name for this business)

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

Leave a Comment

  By clicking "Submit Comment", you agree to our Terms of Service.

We do not publish all comments, and we do not publish comments immediately. The comments feature is a forum to discuss the ideas in our stories. Constructive debate - even pointed disagreement - is welcome, but personal attacks on other commenters are not, and will not be published.

Tip: Do not write a novel. Keep it short. We will not publish lengthy comments. Come up with your own statements. This is not a place to cut and paste an email you received. If we recognize it as such, we won't post it.

Please do not post any comments that are commercial in nature or that violate copyrights.

Finally, we will not publish any comments that we regard as obscene, defamatory, or intended to incite violence.