First two US soldiers killed in Philippines since 2002

They died in a roadside bombing possibly planned by Al Qaeda-linked group Abu Sayyaf. The incident has added to concerns that US troops may be entering into combat, which would violate their rules of engagement.

By International Editor | Correspondent 09.29.09

Two United States soldiers have been killed in a landmine attack in the southern Philippines, marking the first deaths of US troops since 2002. They are believed to have been targeted in a roadside bombing by Abu Sayyaf, the Al Qaeda-linked militant group fighting to carve out an Islamic state.

The incident suggests the continued strength of militants in and around the island of Jolo, despite a sustained military operation to oust them.

It also adds to recent controversy that US counterterrorism troops assisting the Philippines military as advisers are breaking their rules of engagement and entering into combat with Abu Sayyaf militants.

One Philippine marine was also killed in the attack, and two wounded, reports the Associated Press.

The battle for control of Sulu, a southern province comprised of several islands, is small by military standards. Abu Sayyaf is believed to have only 400 militants left in the area, and the US military presence on the ground is only 600, according to the AP.

But the conflict has led to dozens of deaths, several large terrorist attacks, and kidnappings. Militant leaders have eluded capture for years, thanks to the rugged terrain and their jungle hideouts.

The deaths come as the Philippines military launched an operation last month against Abu Sayyaf in the area that has left 53 people dead, including eight Philippine Marines killed last week, according to Reuters.

Tuesday’s attack struck a detachment of marines and US Navy soldiers moving between the villages of Kagay and Luamsaing in Indanan, in Sulu province, which is known as an Abu Sayyaf stronghold, reports the Inquirer, a Philippines English-language newspaper. The US soldiers, who were killed while in a Humvee, were part of an engineering team that was helping to build a road in Kagay, the Inquirer adds.

But another Philippines newspaper, The Mindanao Examiner, says the US soldiers were members of Special Forces, a claim that cannot be verified.

Although security officials deny US forces were directly involved in combat operations, there were numerous reports from civilians that American soldiers actually participated in the operations aimed at capturing or killing militant leaders in Sulu and other areas in the restive southern region of Mindanao.

Officially, US military personnel are not allowed to engage in combat in the Philippines unless attacked, and act only as advisers training the Philippines army in counterinsurgency points out the BBC.

But in recent weeks allegations have surfaced that US troops defied the rules of engagement and entered into combat with Abu Sayyaf militants. Last week US soldiers were accused of opening fire on a mosque in Jolo, the capital of Sulu province, reports the Dateline Philippines news service.

<< ‘Going Rogue’: Sarah Palin’s 400-page book due Nov. 17 | Main

Comments

1. U.S. Marinesgt | 09.29.09

Can anybody tell me what a “U.S. Navy soldier” is?

2. Greg | 09.29.09

Most likely they were Navy Seabees (Construction Battalion) they are the Navys construction force and according to the story they were going to repair a road. That would indicate to me that they were traveling with the Marines which is often the case in operations of this nature.

God please look after our fallen, amen.

3. James | 09.29.09

so what if the US gets involved just let the US soldiers go in there and wipe out those last 400 Abu Sayyaf already this crap has been going on for years and all i ever see are Philippine special interest groups constantly complaining of the US presence

they are a bunch of idiots.. the US military presence is not even on the list of the top 100 problems the Philippines needs to take care of

4. mith | 09.29.09

TO COMMENTS #3 JAMES
YOURE ONE OF THE IDIOTS IN THIS COUNTRY JUST BECAUSE YOU DONT even knows what is… UNITED STATE….stand for…your are worst idiot than philippines people..

5. Jay | 09.29.09

I thought they were Navy SeaBees originally. The Philippines press have released their names and ranks. One is a Staff Sergeant and they other is a Sergeant First Class. This would indicate they were soldiers from the Army and may be part of the Green Beret contingent that is conducting training. Navy SEALS from Sulu have deployed to Manila and Rizal to use their Zodiac boats to conduct rescues in the areas hardest hit by the flooding there.

6. Shull | 09.29.09

The “U.S Navy Soldier” they are referring to was most likely was a SeaBee wearing the camouflague uniform, so he would be hard to differentiate from a infantrymen.

7. Air Force Veteran | 09.30.09

To all please know that “Freedom is not Free” My family and I have always loved serving in the military, regardless of the branch (for over 60 years). Not for what we could get out of them, but because of pride for our country. Some serve 20+ years to one enlistment. Anyway my family is grieving due to the loss of one of our own from this. We ask that you keep us and all other members U.S. Military members and their family is you prayers.

“Support the Troops” (even if you don”t support the war)

8. j-bone | 10.01.09

those men where not seabee’s or “infantrymen”… they where there to help build the philippines though the philippines/phils aren’t worth our time… true social welfare. rip brothers

9. adam | 10.03.09

To all those comments that were negative, not one person has any room to talk if ur military, just for the simple fact those that gave there lives knew what they were getting into, and could happen to anyone of us, its wat we do, its who we are….. and to those that are not military themselfs and talking shouldent, just for the fact that its not supporting but demoralizing if anything…….. RIP to our fallen and God Speed to our serving

10. kyle | 10.05.09

There is a detachment of Seabees in PI curently and they did run into trouble, not this trouble tho. These men were indeed Army, more than likely engineer corps.

May they rest in peace.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

Leave a Comment

  By clicking "Submit Comment", you agree to our Terms of Service.

We do not publish all comments, and we do not publish comments immediately. The comments feature is a forum to discuss the ideas in our stories. Constructive debate - even pointed disagreement - is welcome, but personal attacks on other commenters are not, and will not be published.

Tip: Do not write a novel. Keep it short. We will not publish lengthy comments. Come up with your own statements. This is not a place to cut and paste an email you received. If we recognize it as such, we won't post it.

Please do not post any comments that are commercial in nature or that violate copyrights.

Finally, we will not publish any comments that we regard as obscene, defamatory, or intended to incite violence.