Jake Turcotte
Who’s funnier? McCain, Obama trade jokes over dinner
By Jimmy Orr | 10.17.08
Barack Obama and John McCain appeared together yet again last night, and unlike prior meetings they both came away likable.
Astounding? Yes. In light of three panned debates (although the last one was much better) and with the public’s hatred of the Congress (approval rating 13 percent), the two Senators appeared together at the fancy-schmancy Alfred E. Smith Memorial Foundation Dinner in New York.
Really funny
Only the hardest of partisans could harbor ill feelings toward either of the candidates during the event. McCain and Obama were funny. Really funny. And they even appeared to like each other.
In a sign of the approaching apocalypse, Bill Maher even conceded that McCain was funny.
McCain monologue
Up to bat first for the uber-wealthy, white-tuxedoed crowd was John McCain. And the first part of his opening line must have thrilled New York Times columnist Bill Kristol, who has been advocating for the wholesale firing of McCain’s campaign staff.
“Events are moving fast in my campaign and yes, it’s true that this morning I’ve dismissed my entire team of senior advisers. All of their positions will be now be held by a man named Joe the Plumber,” McCain deadpanned.
The reference, of course, to the previously unknown sorta-plumber John McCain mentioned over 20 times in the third debate as a future victim of Barack Obama’s tax plan.
In the flurry following Joe the Plumber’s debut on the national stage, there has been much buzz that the quasi-plumber wouldn’t make enough to see a tax increase under Obama’s plan.
No matter.
“What they don’t know,” McCain explained, “…is that Joe the Plumber recently signed a very lucrative contract with a wealthy couple to handle all the work on all seven of their houses.”
The reference to McCain’s August “housing-gaffe” drew much laughter, applause, and smiles across the room — including a relaxed Barack Obama who seemed to be genuinely enjoying McCain’s self-immolation.
Underdog
Acknowledging that he was the underdog, McCain said that even in a setting of “proud Manhattan Democrats” he had a feeling that there was support in the room for him.
“I’m delighted to see you here tonight, Hillary,” he said pointing to Obama’s former rival.
Bill Clinton
McCain then asked where husband Bill was — acknowleding that the former president had a “subtle approach” to campaigning for Obama’s presidency.
“When a reporter asked him if Obama was qualified to be President, Bill Clinton pointed out, ‘Sure, he’s over 35 and a U.S. citizen.’ He was pandering to the strict constructionist crowd,” McCain said.
Olbermann
In a monologue interupted numerous times by laughter and applause, the joke that appeared to receive the most cheers was when McCain took a jab at MSNBC.
“It’s going to be a long, long night at MSNBC if I manage to pull this off, ” he said. “I understand that Keith Olbermann offered up his own ‘Mission Accomplished” banner … If they need any decorating advice on that banner, ask Keith to call me so I can tell him right where to put it.”
Obama-time
Barack Obama was not upstaged by the Arizona Senator despite his faux displeasure at holding the event at the Waldorf-Astoria.
“I was originally told we’d be able to move this outdoors to Yankee stadium, and — can somebody tell me what happened to the Greek columns that I requested?” he asked, lampooning the venue and stagecrafting set up for him at the Democratic National Convention.
Taking an immediate jab at Sarah Palin, he offered, “I do love the Waldorf-Astoria. You know, I hear that from the doorstep you can see all the way to the Russian Tearoom.”
Oh, Joe…
His own running mate was fair game as well.
“At one of these campaign rallies, someone in the crowd started yelling, ‘no-bama,’ announcing to everyone in the room that I shouldn’t be the Democratic nominee because there were far more qualified candidates. I really wish Joe Biden hadn’t done that,” he said.
Riffing right from recent news events, Obama announced the topic of his remarks.
“Recently, one of John’s top advisers told the Daily News that if we keep talking about the economy, McCain’s going to lose. So, tonight I’d like to talk about the economy,” he deadpanned, perfectly.
Economy
In regards to the nation’s economy and housing crisis, Obama upped the ante on McCain’s earlier remark stating, “And while the collapse of the housing market’s been tough on every single home owner, I think we all need to recognize that this crisis has been eight times harder on John McCain.”
Who is?
Mocking some of McCain’s recent campaign commercials which ask the question, “Who is Barack Obama?” the Democratic nominee offered a full explanation.
“Contrary to the rumors you have heard, I was not born in a manger. I was actually born on Krypton and sent here by my father Jor El to save the planet Earth,” he said.
As for his middle name “Hussein” which sadly has become an issue to fringe elements on the right, Obama sought to clear up an urban myth, “First of all, my middle name is not what you think. It’s actually Steve. That’s right. Barack Steve Obama.”
Watch John McCain’s monologue here.
Watch Barack Obama’s monogue here.
<< Forget Palin - McCain needs Joe the Plumber | MainComments
2. J.Jay | 10.17.08
I think McCain ruled event. The best I got from Obama was when he said “I palled around with punks upto no good when I joined The United States senate”.
3. Harold | 10.17.08
Moose or Plumber?
Obama told Joe, he wanted to spread the wealth around, not his wealth, our wealth.
How does it work: If 95% of the people are going to get help, But only about 60 % pay taxes, I guess that explains the spread it around part. Any revenue exceeding $250,000 would be subject to a 39 percent tax instead of the current tax rate of 36 percent.
If I have two houses; He Obama, will take one because I only need one, and give one to his friend in Chicago who doesn’t have one. It’s only fair.
So, the socialists are attacking the plumber personally to detract from the mandatory taxation that would prohibit growth and job creation for small businesses.
4. Everett Urech | 10.17.08
I caught the dinner on C-Span last night. It was a good feeling that in our country two bitterly opposed candidates could get together for humorous jabs at themselves and each other. In other places in the world there would be gunfire.
I think the Cardinal looked the most “presidential”.
7. Mohamad Sharzaman | 10.17.08
McCane was much funnier.
Regarding Obama’s changed middle name from Hussain to now Steve. Is this change ligit. Also, it didn’t change the fact that his two other names are Arabic muslim names. Barack Obama.
8. Saxxon Domela | 10.17.08
Its nice to see some actual civility and decency on the part of the candidates. Both candidates did themselves a world of good by being decent to each other, even if done in a humours manner.
9. Bill Finch | 10.17.08
If the candidates had this kind of good humor throughout the campaign I think we would all feel a lot better, and would also feel a lot better about them. Part of my reason for voting for a particular candidate will be to vote against the most negative one.
10. eco delsol | 10.17.08
I was surprisingly rolling on the floor laughing my foolish head off. I honestly saw the real people inside these two men. Both McCain and Obama did great. But to answer the question, McCain was funnier. It will so nice when this campaign is over so we can see the “real” person instead of the campaigning buffoon. 
11. Avery | 10.17.08
I think it was funny as heck, I found myself laughing at both of them nearly the entire time. It would be nice to see more of this but politics just aren’t that way.
12. Gregg | 10.17.08
What’s really hilarious is that every election, we end up with no third party candidate at these carefully scripted debates and end up having to hold our nose at the voting booth as we vote for one of two stinking corporate-sponsored candidates from the Republicrat cartel. Both stand for perpetual war, sun-setting of the Constitution in favor of some globalist entity, and and bailout of corrupt bankers at the expense of the prudent bankers and hard-working taxpayers who lived within their means.
13. Tim Lingenfelder | 10.17.08
I find it incredibly refreshing that both candidates can sit in a room and be cordial, even chummy. If we all tried just a little bit harder to do the same, perhaps we’d all be a little happier.
I don’t agree with everyone, but I respect the differences of opinions. Bashing someone for feeling or believing differently doesn’t do anything positive.
This story left me with a good feeling about both candidates and the humanity behind them.
tim
14. princess | 10.17.08
All candidates say what they are going to do and no one evey does it. So why does it matter how they get along with each other? Once they get elected they put plan ‘B’ into motion and pull the wool over our eyes, as usual.
15. FedUp | 10.17.08
The “Emperors” fiddled while Rome burnes!!! and none of them know where the fire hose is, or worse, how to use it. Hey Joe, did you get an invite or did Obama give it to the guy behind you? Folks, we need a serious house cleaning back there. The fox is tending our chicken coop.We are in serious trouble.
16. LFforMcCain | 10.17.08
I thought McCain was remarkably funny. I’ve never known him to be like that. Obama, oddly, wasn’t very funny and looked uncomfortable. It was uncomforatble watching Obama and I really related to McCain which is odd because it’s usually the other way around since Obama is normally the better speaker in these situations. McCain is really very funny!
17. Arne Saknussemm | 10.17.08
I’ve seen people far more funnier and presidential at the dinner.
Obama will most likely be the next president but he needs to take care of his attitude a bit. I’m talking the condescending/ironic smile when someone attacks or annoyes him. A president or mature politician, not a wannabe, should take criticism with honor.
18. Kristina | 10.17.08
It’s now about Joe, it’s about America…. so the real issue is not taxes because if the economy is bad, we loose jobs and don’t pay taxes.
The ironic thing is we are loosing jobs like crazy and have exported 2/3rd’s of them. Only two industries left, housing & banking, (http://www.BuyMyHouseBeforeTheBankTakesIt.com ) are crashing. We refuse to produce products in the US, and there is going to be a day where nobody will be making $250,000 after dust settles. A very important fact, 1 out of 6 in American is finance related. The tax plan is a mood point if we don’t reinvest in our country.
We are no longer producers; our stores have been invaded by foreign products. Every purchase we make goes to feeding someone else’s family in communist China. Thirty percent of gas you purchase goes to terrorist. It does not have to be this way. We need to be supporting our own communities.
Interesting thing, my brother is a robotics engineer and can take and revamp any US company make it more profitable and more efficient that it would be cheaper to produce here.
So let’s get off our lazy buts, start using our brains and become innovative again. Lets use our American brain power and innovation to make new products here and ship them overseas. Our country needs industry and American needs to be talking talk about and growth not taxation.
19. mandy | 10.17.08
McCain is intellictual and funny. i enjoyed every words he said . God will help him.
20. Tahir | 10.17.08
This banquet dinner was a comedy session. i was laughing so hard. McCain stole the show and was way funnier than Obama.
22. Nemo | 10.17.08
I think McCain was a lot funnier…Obama was good but McCain was better….too bad this does not count…
24. Trish | 10.17.08
John McCain was at the top of his game last night. He was very, very funny. Sorry, Obama was pathetic.
Unless we get back to our roots; U.S. Constitution as it was intended to be by the founding fathers, faith, family, flag, and freedom, we will lose our liberty, and ultimately our lives.
FIGHT for our freedoms. Live rightly. Build ourselves into a moral, responsible, Godly people, and all our problems will be resolved.
25. James | 10.17.08
“If we keep talking about the economy, McCain’s going to lose. So, tonight I’d like to talk about the economy ” Very funny
26. Ken from Ohio | 10.17.08
McCain displayed the funnier routine when you compare them as comedians. Obama better handled the role of a candidate for President who just happens to have a sense of humor.
Maybe after the election, McCain can look to a new career.
27. Eric | 10.17.08
Obama was a stiff suit. Not a funny bone in his body. He had some good lines written by some people but horrible delivery.
28. Peter | 10.17.08
I really enjoyed both of them; however, I think McCain did much better when it comes to funny and rolling his eyes.
During this difficult time in our lives, I just wish we have one political party and one government where we can focus more on the critical issues, the two wars and the financial crisis, instead of worrying who and which political party is going to be blamed for the next 4 years.
29. Stacey-Florida | 10.17.08
I thought last night was like a breath of fresh air. I’ve seen John McCain on “The Daily Show with Jon Stewart.” He’s a funny guy! It was inspiring to see both candidates being what they are first and foremost - PEOPLE. After they’re presidents, senators, govenors, congressmen, they go back to being people. As much as I dislike George Bush’s politics, I think he’d be a fun neighbor. When I saw him take a telephone call from his daughter while she was on “The Ellen Show,” it made me remember he is a Dad. He talked to her just as a father should. He wasn’t pompous, presidential, otious…He was just Dad. And after 1/20/09, **** still be Dad.
31. Scarlett | 10.17.08
I enjoyed both candidates, but McCain got my vote for the most humorous. Senator Clinton got my vote for the best sport and for the one that genuinely laughed loudest. McCain and Clinton were joys to watch.
The man seated behind the podium, in full camera view, who ate with his mouth open and never ceased eating his din din, was the one that received my vote for RUDE — he was so engrossed in eating that he never once smiled or laughed — due to his seating position, I assumed the man was one of the
so-called elite figures; however, not in my opinion is he elite.
32. Bill | 10.17.08
Of course both scripts were written by professional writers. So the question is who had better delivery? McCain was funnier because of incongruity with his normal demeanor and because he gave himself over to the moment. Obama was less funny because he is fundamentally a serious person, and because he wasn’t 100% in the moment. He was running for president.
33. Franky | 10.17.08
Both were very funny, but McCain was more of a surprise to me!
I hope all the hateful people out there saw this event, and now know these are two real men.
34. Lee | 10.17.08
McCain imo. His jokes were funnier. Obama’s jokes just weren’t that funny and he doesn’t seem like he’s the funny type anyway. You get the feeling he takes himself a little too seriously and that is not conducive to humor.
35. Sarah | 10.17.08
Both of these monologues delighted me, and I was even more delighted to see these important and influential men displaying bon homme. I hope this is a prelude to the post-campaign era when we will need the best and the brightest of all parties to work together in good faith and good will to lead our nation to solutions. I thank all who organized, funded, attended, broadcasted, and most especially Senator Obama and Senator McCain for participating in this demonstration of American leadership.
36. Ken | 10.17.08
I am very much an Obama fan and do not find McCain’s campaign misbehavior in the least bit amusing.
However, McCain’s performance at the Al Smith dinner was much funnier.
Indeed, McCain would be a far better stand-up comic than President.
37. robbie | 10.17.08
LOL @ ” McCane was much funnier.”
you don’t know how to spell his name?
“Regarding Obama’s changed middle name from Hussain to now Steve. Is this change ligit. Also, it didn’t change the fact that his two other names are Arabic muslim names. Barack Obama.”
Help explain to me how Kenyan first and last names are 1 ) Muslim and 2) Arabic
You may be interested to know Kenya isn’t an Arabic country. Or perhaps you wouldn’t be interested to know and would like to continue a sad ignorant person.
38. Julio Los Angeles, CA | 10.17.08
I think Mr. McCain, was very funny and probably was funnier than Mr.Obama in some way. I also think when Mr. McCain is happy and funny looks better.
But, that doesn’t mean that I will vote for him.
I am a Obama supporter.
I also want to express my sincere respects for the people who think different than me!
39. marlene | 10.17.08
I think McCain was funnier, although I am a passionate Obama supporter. This was good practice for Barack. He is not a natural with this Irish humor of self-deprecation, sarcasim, all that knock-out wit. But he is a quick study, and this experience will help him pick up a lighter touch. I always liked McCain, but began to mistrust my former respect for him when he so blatentedly picked up that swiftboat tactic that sideswiped him when he ran against George Bush. It was dismaying to witness. He will be gald when this is over, and his ability to laugh at himself, be a decent sport, etc. was encourageing. His remarks about Obama, that were to be taken seriously, was about his race. I think he meant the reference as a compliment, I reallly do. But it didn’t sit well. Race should not have been mentioned because Obama never refers to it. So that was a below the belt punch, although perhaps it was not meant to have that effect.
40. Jim Campbell | 10.17.08
New format for the debates? Now that’s the best idea I’ve heard in a long time. http://www.LikeSoup.com
41. Stacey-Florida | 10.17.08
Something I found very interesting was the dude in the middle of the 2 of them. Doesn’t he know Halloween isn’t until October 31st? Was he dressed up as Dracula, with the cape and all? If so, everyone knows Dracula wasn’t Jewish. So, he needs to lose the yarmulke. And, is this a spin on the famous Count? Is this Count Blingula? Did you see all the gold rings he was sporting? The red and gold outfit was a little on the “flaming” side, if you know what I mean.
43. AZIndependent | 10.17.08
I am an Obama supporer but McCain’s delivery was better than Obama’s. Good thing Obama will be President soon because as a comedian he is lacking.
44. Da Truth | 10.17.08
McCain was much funnier….. I watched, in total, both of their speeches and McCain was more relaxed and on queue. His jokes were much more clever. Obama seemed a bit off-queue and more stiff, and his jokes were no where near as clever (he even had to laugh at a few of his own, because no one else was laughing).
The media has fawned over and favored Obama SO much that he often seems more sure of himself [because he knows the media (and Hollywood) has his back]. Is it possible that last nights ‘somewhat’ more spontaneous (and less choreographed) situation allowed McCain to shake off the media’s bias!! Maybe all those years of experienced has prepared him for those ‘unscripted’ situations better. McCain knows that in the debates he has to overcome the media bias (their cameras, their positioning, their moderators, their expectations etc., etc.) and he knows he can not attach too much (which is what those behind in the poles have to do – Repub or Demi-dem).
Of course when the media was fawning over Hillary, Obama was not so sure of himself. Is his self assurance just in knowing that the media will cover for him one way, or the other.
Maybe the media just did not expect McCain to be ‘so’ good last night, but he was !!!
Maybe experience allows you to react on your feet so much better.
45. PBombz | 10.17.08
McCain was hysterical. They way his eyes blinked like a strobe light was a riot, and how he look all out of sorts was an absolute hoot. And when he couldn’t stop saying “America” or “Americans” but nothing of substance in between was a scream. Great stuff.
48. Mack | 10.17.08
Both men were very funny. To be honest, I couldn’t tell which was funnier - but that seems appropriate since this WASN’T supposed to be a debate, town-hall meeting, or anything of the sort. I find it even funnier to see partisan reaction to last nights event. Seems like we can’t even see humor through the shroud of ideology that has fallen over this country.
49. Jorma | 10.17.08
IT was Great seeing both of them relaxed. McCain had more laughs and was funnier, although Obama did get some really good lines in there too, he’s never really been funny so he actually did better than I thought he would.
THe funnies part of the whole night for me was though, watching McCain laughing at Obama’s jokes can you say ‘Akward’ Go back and look at it again, he would clap once or twice try to laugh hard and go back to a dead frown LOL it was the funniest thing of the night for me.
51. Robert | 10.17.08
The point of the article was to leave politics aside… both men were very funny, and I was happy to see this side of them.
Kristina makes a great point. Harold is the usual complaining conservative.
Blah blah blah… socialism, whine whine whine. Your conservative president just put his plan into motion to put many large banks under partial government ownership. I’m not sure that’s socialism, but it sure isn’t capitalism.
And one other thing for all you complaining conservatives who trumpet your patriotism and whine like children about taxes. There are two wars that we are funding at the moment, and we’re in the hole big time in terms of debt and budget deficit. Instead of investing $5 in your American flag lapel pin in order to ‘prove’ your patriotism, how about you stop complaining about taxes, close your mouths, buck up, and pony up with some dough to pay for all these things your conservative administration has pursued. “America’s the greatest country in the world, the most powerful, but golly, I don’t want to pay for any of it”… that’s the conservative mantra.
52. Peace | 10.17.08
It was nice to see both candidates in a setting where everyone was on the same page for a great cause. Why can’t our goverment officials do the same for “our policies” also for a GREAT CAUSE…THE AMERICAN PEOPLE!!!
May God bless them both and THY WILL BE DONE.
54. Obama man | 10.17.08
I think Obama would make a better president but McCain was a lot funnier. Maybe Obama could get him to be the White House jester!!!
55. GLev | 10.17.08
I just read every comment and was rather shocked when I came across I believe it was Harold’s comment that Obama is a socialist. Its unbelivable to me that someone would say something so pathetic, as if John Mccain and President Bush didn’t just use socialism at its worst when signing for that bailout…if this isn’t socialism then please buddy tell me what is? Be even with what you say, they all have voted for socialist agendas and for you to try and say its only obama makes you sound foolish. And to the person saying is “steve” a legit name change, you are even more of a fool, you dimwit. You called Obamas other names “muslim arab names” Muslim simply means a follower of Islam (which Obama is not & a name can’t be Muslim you ignoramus) & being Arab just means being a member of Semitic People, meaning all Jews and Christians including Moses and Jesus were “arab”…watch your words and learn what you are speaking on when doing so.
56. PleaseChange | 10.17.08
Some of you all need to lighten up. They were both hysterical and it was a real relief to see them off the debate stage actually laughing. No matter how bad things get or how strongly you feel about your candidates or your values, we could all use some comic relief right now.
57. RuthE | 10.17.08
I thought That McCain was a little funnier but I think he had the advantage going first. I think that Since Obama ended with talking about Tim Russert that he sort of brought the crowd down steeply. I’m glad Tim was mentioned, what a great man. I think it’s good to see the candidates loosen up a little but and laugh at themselves.
59. Joe the bummer | 10.17.08
God will help McCain??? He might be funny (remarkably George W. Bush is absolutely hilarious), but saying “intellictual” (actually spelled intellectual) is going a tad bit too far. God should help our country (not McCain) if people’s votes are actually being swayed by who is the more humorous candidate.
60. Terry Swanson | 10.17.08
Both Funny. I have liked McCain in the past but not lately. Obama is a phenom of the best kind and i am so proud of him and wish both the best.
61. southern Belle | 10.17.08
I thought they were both hilarious. It’s nice to have some candidates with a sense of humor for a change (think about it: W, Gore, Kerry — what a bunch of buzz kills)! I’ve always thought McCain was funny and endearing on his late night appearances, but my vote’s still proudly going Obama/Biden in ‘08!
62. Ajay | 10.17.08
I think both had good material and did well, But I think McCain was better at delivering his jokes, his timing. His oration, surprisingly was better than Obama’s. McCain was just glancing at this script where as Obama was hanging on to his script (unusual for him), which took some of the edge of his delivery.
63. mslove23 | 10.17.08
they were both funny..but like with the debates, it was scripted. Luckily, we don’t choose a president by how funny he is or isn’t. I still don’t want Palin as president!!!!
64. Hunter | 10.17.08
I found McCain to be funnier than Obama and I think it gave viewers a better idea of which man does better in speaches/debates when the media/hosts can’t help them. McCain/Palin’08
65. Da Truth | 10.17.08
Something I think is kin-da funny. Left winger like to call conservatives ‘wingnuts’ as short for ‘right wing nuts’.
However, at lest conservatives are the high quality nuts – like Cashews, Almonds & Walnuts.
The bonnerless, bonehead left-wingers are just Acorns.
They tend to litter the ground this time of year.
In comparison to the ‘wingnuts’ they are soft, mushy and easily crushed under foot !!
66. Faith | 10.17.08
There is a time to laugh and a time to cry. This event surely provoked some much needed laughter around our living room yesterday, and in other people’s homes as I can see above. Seeing Hilary Clinton laugh so hard was good. I enjoyed her laughs. Everyone needs to get loose once in a while.
67. Robert NYC | 10.17.08
That was hilarious. I did notice McCain made fun of himself while Obama still used it to make any point he could against McCain. McCain was loose and seemed to be really enjoying himself while Obama was a bit of a stiff suit. ironic yes? I guess the jokes were not on a teleprompter?
68. Sarah | 10.17.08
McCain is like Jekyll and Hyde. He was engaging at the dinner show, completely annoying otherwise…
69. Joe | 10.17.08
I think Harold is the funniest. You should read more. And relax.
Well done both cadidates
70. Art Tendler | 10.17.08
This will be the only election in history where the WINNER will ask for a recount!!
What a lousy Job. And the pay isn’t that great either!
71. mkell | 10.17.08
Its really interesting (sad) how some of the comments attack the lighthearted gestures proffered by last nights benefit. I thought both men were incredibly funny, and I got to watch their acts more than once. To be honest, they were even funnier than SNL could ever be. However, I was truly delighted that each candidate dedicated a moment in their monologues to heap praise on one another.
That was inspiring.
We all knew McCain could do it, but you have to give some props to Obama - his material was genuinely funny and his delivery was impeccable for the most part. I was shocked. And awed.
72. Sillyme | 10.17.08
I watched this last night and I have to say they were both very funny. Obama was laughing so hard at McCain’s jokes that I thought his face might split open and the same for John McCain. I’ve never seen him more relaxed and genuinely smiling. I thought it was a refreshing break from the race and liked seeing them both being themselves. It was nice to temporarily lay down the hatchets. I DO believe that this was the real John McCain that somehow got buried during his campaign. Its a shame too because although he’s not my pick, I could have felt more respect for him. But again both were very funny.
73. Kev | 10.17.08
As a stong supporter of Obama, I have to admit that I felt McCain had me laughing the hardest. He felt like a comic feeding and reacting to the crowd. His material ran smooth and had a good flow. His good words for Obama felt honest and he did say alot of good things.
Obama did a good job as well, but it more quick little jokes and jabs. I think this is the first time we have seen him out of his element and he still rose to the event.
I loved how McCain built up the expectation that Obama would give a great speach. He was able to pull alot of material from that has he handed the stage over to Obama.
74. JoeB | 10.17.08
Great stuff. I really ended up liking McCain even though I have soured on him lately. I thought he was a tad bit funnier than Obama.
The fat cardinal in his silk costume with the twin wine goblets before him was the one who turned me off. Sure did not look to me like a representative of Christ to me.
75. muffin | 10.17.08
Obama was sooooooo much funny than McCain and delivered so much better. Maybe you should go back and watch again!
76. Stacey-Florida | 10.17.08
47. SamAsh | 10.17.08
I weep at the apparent lack of humor that a lot of you seem to exhibit.
———————————————————————-
It is you with the apparent lack of humor. How often do you see a male cross dresser in full costume sitting between the 2 presidential candidates? How is that not hysterical? You should “Google” Cardinal Egan if you want to read about really nasty politics.
77. Soupy Sales | 10.17.08
John McCain saw Bill Maher’s “Religulous” and loved it. I’m now voting for McCain because he doesn’t believe in all that silly, christian hoo-hah. Hooray for science and reason!!!
78. sonny | 10.17.08
I like both of these guys. They are hilarious and very funny. But my vote is for obama because of that self proclaimed experienced moose hunter. She is an absolute jerk in politics. ..not only dumb and delusional but scary and quite dangerous. What spewed out from that mouth is a classic example of hate speech…may she could not understand the underlying consequences of those sentences.
79. Hilary Smith | 10.17.08
I guess this is one of those instances where you “just had to be there.”
80. Stacey-Florida | 10.17.08
47. SamAsh | 10.17.08
I weep at the apparent lack of humor that a lot of you seem to exhibit.
———————————————————————-
It is you with the apparent lack of humor. How often do you see a male cross dresser in full costume sitting between the 2 presidential candidates? How is that not hysterical? You should “Google” Cardinal Egan if you want to read about really nasty politics.
81. y bother | 10.17.08
What I don’t understand is how this question is legitimate enough to help anyone decide who is the better candidate for president. Are we electing a national comedian or someone who is going to bring this country out of a financial and economic crisis? Obama is the better candidate hands down.
82. Drefish | 10.17.08
It was funny. Although watching Obama laugh at his own jokes you could tell it wasn’t his natural style to be humorous. It also felt like listening to my old teachers in College cracking jokes during a lecture.
83. tdub | 10.17.08
Both candidates were quite funny. Nice to see both candidates putting aside their stark differences for a night of laughter for a good cause. Too bad some people in this talkback can’t put aside their own selfish desires, still trying to to “pick a winner” on who was funnier that night. As if that means something important in the big picture. I just thought it was nice to see both McCain and Obama in a more informal setting, both showing elements of their personality we are normally unable to see in such a divisive and serious campaign.
84. BETTY FINZER | 10.17.08
Let’s face it! McCain is funnier, more intelligent when it comes to
running our country, more compassionate, sincere, and humble.
Come on, folks, wake up! There is no comparison in my book who is more
qualified. ThUs said, I agree with the person who said “May God bless them
both and THY WILL BE DONE!
bjf
85. Dave | 10.17.08
Good observations, Stacey. I also noticed the unusual garb.
Also, I liked Obama’s line about fathering two African-american children. Very funny.
86. Hillary Supporter | 10.17.08
Judging from her reaction, Hillary thought McCain was a lot funnier.
87. JC | 10.17.08
I have to say it was one of the best moments recently for both candidates. I nearly regained my respect for McCain after the last few weeks of ugly Obama smears. I listened on the radio and I felt McCain actually delivered the best jokes. Obama seemed a bit out of his element. Still, it was highly enjoyable.
88. Digital SLR Camera | 10.17.08
I thought McCain said a few funny things, but Obama had me rolling the whole time.
All the people above that said McCain did better, are obviously his supporters.
89. Philip Pierce | 10.17.08
Heard in front of the Russian Tea Room:
“Remember, We’re watching you while you’re watching us!”
90. Mike in Sac | 10.17.08
They were both very funny. You have to give them both points. Unless you are so ideological you have lost perspective. McCain is noted to have a really good sense of humor, but I didn’t know Obama had one as well.
I also like both their comments at the end. McCain behavior during the debates left me wondering if he had a bigotry problem, but he made a good case that he is not a bigot and I half believe him.
Obama was much more inspirational. This event was about charitable efforts and his case for those sorts of efforts really resonated.
91. Common Sense | 10.17.08
( robbie
“Regarding Obama’s changed middle name from Hussain to now Steve. Is this change ligit. Also, it didn’t change the fact that his two other names are Arabic muslim names. Barack Obama.”
Help explain to me how Kenyan first and last names are 1 ) Muslim and 2) Arabic
You may be interested to know Kenya isn’t an Arabic country. Or perhaps you wouldn’t be interested to know and would like to continue a sad ignorant person)
Dear Robbie,
FOR REAL? Christianity started in Israel so aren’t you interested on how it spread to American, China, and Europe? I’m very interested in what the difference is between an Arabic and Muslim name? Care to explain? Are there no people who practice Islam in Kenya? How about America? Are there no people with Arabic AND Muslim names born in America? You act like Obama picked his name. Please grow up. It is a name, only a name. Just like Matthew, Mark, Luke and John are names. People given those names by their parents have done bad things, right? The man is named after his father by the way. Do you think he picked his father as well as his own name?
92. happyweasel | 10.17.08
McCain’s speech was hilarious. I’m an Obama supporter and have donated to his campaign, but whoever wrote/responsible for the text of McCain’s speech needs an award and a pay hike. Obama’s speech was staid, cautious, & respectful. McCain’s was balls-out comedy.
93. crossroads | 10.17.08
This is for “Harold’s” comments. The plumber wasn’t licensed, and you need to be where he works, neither is the owner of the company, he isn’t registered to vote, and has a 1200 dollar tax lien he hasn’t paid. Sounds like a typical Republican, underqualified, avoids paying taxes, and if he does come up with the money, would want a tax break because he was “wealthy”.
94. mc | 10.17.08
Obama sure can deliver those speeches, but he just couldn’t pull off those jokes! McCain was so much funnier.
95. just saying | 10.17.08
Who was better? Why did somebody have to win? I took this for what it was. A charity affair with some great comic relief from all the heavy campaigning. I wish we could do “roasts” from now until Nov. 4th.
96. J.Jay | 10.17.08
TO, #42. Stacey-Florida | 10.17.08
If you are saying that jokingly than it was not funny and if you really don’t know who he is, than you need to get your ugly ignorant behind off the comfortable couch and need to find out. Give the guy and his outfit some respect just the way you respect outfit of a soldier.
97. Art | 10.17.08
How about we don’t turn this into a “who won the comedy routine” contest. Isn’t there enough of that already. They were both funny. It was a moment of levity in an otherwise tense campaign. Good for them.
98. Steve Brandt | 10.17.08
It warmed my heart to see some hard-working, senior politicians having a good time and jabbing at themselves. It strikes me a sad, on the other hand, to know that our current, elected leaders, including Bush, Cheney, Polosi, Franks and others, are hiding out. They sneak out into the shadows to point fingers, but otherwise are unseen whlle the rest of the country wiggles and scrapes to find out what went wrong and why. And who.
99. Einstein’s Daughter | 10.17.08
“White-tuxedoed?” Honey, only Cab Calloway wore a white tuxedo. The proper term is “white tie,” which implies the most formal evening wear including a tail coat.
And by the way, what exactly is the Alfred E. Smith Memorial Foundation and why does it draw both presidential candidates?
100. Jolene | 10.17.08
Sen. McCain (a.k.a. GREAT AMERICAN HERO) rocked and ruled last night! Too funny!
BTW, for those of you who believe our great country’s current economic crisis is a result of “Conservatism,” perhaps you should go back to U.S.Government 101 and review role of Congress.
I’m proud to be a U.S. flag pin wearing American Patriot, who loves her country dearly, pays plenty in taxes and doesn’t whine.
May God bless America, our troops serving everywhere and their families.
102. Rita | 10.17.08
I’m a staunch Obama supporter but I have to say that McCain was funnier last night.
103. Brigitte | 10.17.08
They were both funny.
I think Obama appealed more to the younger crowd, and Mccain to the older crowd.
104. Kuku | 10.17.08
They were both really funny. That was really a pleasant encounter between the two candidates. IF they could show this sides of thier character often, it would be lot more hilarious. With such a great exchange between the two candidates, I would be very dissappointed to see one of those Mccain’s terrible ads again on tv. Let him save the money for charity
105. Looie | 10.17.08
Did Obama think that he would not look “presidential” if he relaxed a little? He was stiff and it seemed to me that he waited for the laughs after each line. McCain had them laughing throughout.
McCain was hilarious! He had some good zingers and delivered them very well!
106. Lib | 10.17.08
Why does everything have to turng into a competition?! What - we’re going to vote for the funniest candidate?
Competition - it brings out the worst in everybody
107. erik | 10.17.08
I’m very impressed from the reactions to both and who was funnier. Personally I thought Obama was better but both where good. I think it is very telling about generational differences but it also confirmed what I already know. We need a future not a past, We need progressive thought not what has already proved its outdated and ineffective.
108. mike | 10.17.08
McCain should stick to his dinner parties, it is what he does best. I really think thats who he is and who he has been.
109. Joe | 10.17.08
Oh, too funny - this comment ->
——————————————–
Something I found very interesting was the dude in the middle of the 2 of them. Doesn’t he know Halloween isn’t until October 31st? Was he dressed up as Dracula, with the cape and all? If so, everyone knows Dracula wasn’t Jewish. So, he needs to lose the yarmulke. And, is this a spin on the famous Count? Is this Count Blingula? Did you see all the gold rings he was sporting? The red and gold outfit was a little on the “flaming” side, if you know what I mean.
——————————————-
Count Blingula? lmao, maybe you should have been there giving the speech….
111. Looie | 10.17.08
McCain had EVERYBODY laughing! Brigitte — are you saying Hillary and Katie Couric are “old”???
I saw Bloomberg laughing quite a bit during Obama’s skit…he’s no young chap.
112. Twila Anderson | 10.17.08
It was refreshing to see the event of last evening. Humor can be healing and as a nation we certainly need to heal from these past few weeks.
However, the gentleman that was eating his din din behind the Senator McCain was a hoot. He ate with his mouth open, dipped food when required and then licked his fingers clean. His face was motionless unless he was reaching for something to fill his face again. It nearly looked like he was put there on purpose for more laughs. I thought that was the end of the eating project until he waited for Senator Obama to begin and then he displayed his napkin for all to see the food by raising it up before folding it up and laying it down. It was hilarious I tell you! Thanks
113. Jean | 10.17.08
Both were funny.. and Obama’s toothy grin was great… McCain’s good nature of laughing while Obama was up there… very stately/funny. Both guys showed lots of class and good naturedness.
It really helped me to not dislike Obama as much as I do.
I will still vote for McCain. because Obama is clearly for the GOVERNMENT running our lives. That’s what other countries do and THEY all want to come to AMERICA to get away from!!!!!!!!!!!
I will NEVER vote for a Democrat for that very reason!
I wish all of us were Independents and vote for those who have 90% of what we believe in.. instead of our biased sides. ALL SO CHILDISH!
I also believe NO PRESIDENT does his job all by himself… If McCain wins and then dies an early death with Palin becoming president.. not to fear.. She will not be doing anything alone. Bush has had a DEMOCRATIC congress and life got very messy……… YOU NEVER HEAR THAT… for that I will NEVER vote Democratic.. They NEVER admit to anything. They played such a huge role with Barney Frank…but you NEVER heard that on biased media channels. It makes me sick.. I listen, I want to hear it all but you ONLY get half the story from the media.
114. Jennifer | 10.17.08
I am an Obama supporter, but McCain was definitely funnier last night. Obama got crikets when he compared the dinner to an AIG event, but I really think that was targeted at the average American viewer.
Obama’s delivery was better, especially when he would look over his shoulder, but McCain’s demeanor, yellow smile, and laugh made his jokes funnier.
I don’t know how SNL will make fun of Obama if he should win the presidency.
Obama ‘08
115. Hutch | 10.17.08
I’m an Obama supporter, but I think McCain’s speech made me laugh a little more and did quite a bit to humanize the guy… it was more like the McCain I remember going on “The Daily Show” and trading jabs with Jon Stewart.
Still doesn’t make me more comfortable with the idea of a McCain presidency, but it was great to see both candidates go up on stage, poke a little fun at themselves and the opponent, and have a good laugh…something that was badly needed as things continue to get ugly on the campaign, which is why I don’t think it’s right to ask “who’s funnier?” as if the event was about scoring political points.
It was about reminding the voters that the candidates are human.
W
ell done to both John and Barack…now let’s get back to the insanity.
116. Marilyn | 10.17.08
Did anyone notice the thunderous applause McCain got when he said that he knew there were people in the heavily Democrat room rooting for him??? and that it was going to be a long night for MSNBC if he managed to pull this thing out???
Obama was too serious, flat, stoic and at times he seemed to wait for the laughter. I guess he did not want to lose his “presidential” demeanor.
McCain truly made me laugh, great delivery of lines!
117. AndreinFL | 10.17.08
“the funniest part was McCain’s reactions to Obama jokes, that was Hillarious!!”
Yeh i was laughing when mccain picked up the glass of water; he reminded me of a T-REX dinosoaur
118. tod | 10.17.08
both funny !!
Do you prefer redistribution of wealth to CEOs, oil companies or to the middle class ?
http://therealmccain.com/
119. Maria | 10.17.08
I love Obama but whoever wrote McCain’s lines did a better job. Obama/Biden 08
121. Maggie | 10.17.08
Who cares who was funnier? Isn’t it nice that they managed to call off the dogs for a minute so that everybody in this country could take a break from all the negativity? Obviously, judging by some of these comments, some people can’t get away from negativity. Get over it. Go have a drink and a smile. Thank God that the gas prices have gone down, even if it is for a day. Be positive about something in your life just once. Try it.
122. laurel slaninka | 10.17.08
John McCain was by far the funnier. Obama didn’t get nearly as much applause and he did laugh whole-heartedly at a lot of McCain jokes. I thought McCain was hilarious and got by far the most applause.
I stayed up the watched McCain on Dave Letterman where he was also funny. John McCain has a real sense of humor! Obama does have a sense of humor but the audience didn’t seem to get a lot of his jokes. It was nice to see them in such an informal situation that they seemed to respect and enjoy each other, which brings hope to our country. I will vote for McCain however.
123. Becki | 10.17.08
McCain won hands down. He seemed relaxed and comfortable and displayed a great sense of humor. It was nice to see that side of him. Obama was funny too, but McCain seemed to have better material which was a little surprising. It was great to to see both candidates laughing and enjoying each other’s good natured jabs.
124. Absolivious | 10.17.08
McCain sense of humor finally came through. I especially liked McCain’s wrap-up, setting up Obama by telling the crowd to expect the funniest 15 minutes of their lives. Obama’s Yankee stadium and Greek column comment was good but his finish was too much pontification for the occasion.
McCain didn’t do badly on Dave Letterman either where he even admitted publicly that he had “screwed up” when he canceled his earlier scheduled appearance only 90 minutes before taping.
125. Don | 10.17.08
You can’t all be this stupid. They had comedy speech writers. The only real thing that was said was the endings.
Also to the stupid people that talk about his arab name. It’s African you idiots. The only name with arabic origins is his middle name.
126. katrina | 10.18.08
I am really surprised that such a balanced publication like the CS Monitor has drawn such a one-sided bunch of opinions. Very pro-McCain, little pro-Obama.
So, just to balance, I say GO OBAMA. And I like his jokes better than McCain’s. Vote for STEVE.
I dread any other “linked” Republican in the the Presidency, and McCain has the Republican Stain. Sorry, but you will never convince me otherwise. He nailed my opinion with his political pick of Palin.
It is time for Real Change - for the better.
127. Duda | 10.18.08
I think we need to have these in place of the debates. The debates themselves brought nothing but negativity to my mind about both candidates. This event cleared it up. I don’t want to vote for someone who spews out ideas just to please the public. I want to vote for a human being. Otherwise, I’d just vote for a computer to take charge.
128. Tom Chula | 10.18.08
Obama was good. We need a president who can be serious, even when telling jokes. Mccain was a little too comfortable, maybe he should stick to entertainment!
129. RMW | 10.18.08
By the Way, Kenya may not be arabic but Islam is the second MAJOR religion after Christianity in Kenya….
130. Stan | 10.18.08
McCain was pretty good, but BObama was much funnier! I could not stop laughing!
It was good to see the warm side to each candidate.
131. ChazV | 10.19.08
Two great men who both knocked it out of the park. I think McCain when he is natural he takes on a wonderful likeablity about him and could win anyone over. It was nice to see the humor side of Obama who always appears to serious.
Imagine trying to do stand up comedy they way they did. What extraordinary individuals these two men are.
132. Stacey-Florida | 10.20.08
110. Joe | 10.17.08
Oh, too funny - this comment ->
——————————————–
Something I found very interesting was the dude in the middle of the 2 of them. Doesn’t he know Halloween isn’t until October 31st? Was he dressed up as Dracula, with the cape and all? If so, everyone knows Dracula wasn’t Jewish. So, he needs to lose the yarmulke. And, is this a spin on the famous Count? Is this Count Blingula? Did you see all the gold rings he was sporting? The red and gold outfit was a little on the “flaming” side, if you know what I mean.
——————————————-
Count Blingula? lmao, maybe you should have been there giving the speech
_______________________________________________________________________
Thanks, Joe. I’m humbled at your appreciation of my observation. I was lmao when I was typing it. Catholicism is another form of government using christianity as a smoke screen to make $$$. After all, if jesus(providing he is real) showed up here on earth today, would he really say, “You chrisitans got my message right on the money! This is exactly what I meant!”? I don’t think so.
133. catarina | 10.25.08
I’m going to dress as BO for Halloween. I’ll get a mask, a suit, a few cigs and carry two sacks of money and spread the wealth around Then, when I get my bar tab, I’ll pay it, but leave the tip for someone that needs it…maybe I’ll find a homeless person.
Let’s see how well that goes over with the bartender ha 
Anyone thinking that BO was more funny than McCain is drinking BO’s bathwater.
134. Mware | 10.29.08
Both candidates were simply hilarious. McCain, was a complete surprise to me - extremely funny. However, Go Obama.
I am Kenyan and to set the record straight 80% of Kenya is Christian, about 18% is Islamic and 2% other religions. Barack is from the swahili word “baraka” which means blessing.
I hope and pray that both candidates can work together (after the elections) regardless of who wins the election.
All the best to your nation.
Trackbacks/Pingbacks
2. Political Blog Posts» Blog Archive » Who=92s funnier? McCain, Obama trade jokes over dinner | 10.18.08
Leave a Comment
We do not publish all comments, and we do not publish comments immediately. The comments feature is a forum to discuss the ideas in our stories. Constructive debate - even pointed disagreement - is welcome, but personal attacks on other commenters are not, and will not be published.
Tip: Do not write a novel. Keep it short. We will not publish lengthy comments. Come up with your own statements. This is not a place to cut and paste an email you received. If we recognize it as such, we won't post it.
Please do not post any comments that are commercial in nature or that violate copyrights.
Finally, we will not publish any comments that we regard as obscene, defamatory, or intended to incite violence.
Jimmy Orr has worked in politics for the majority of his professional career working for two U.S. Senators, two Governors and one President. Most recently, Orr served as White House Spokesman and Internet Director for President George W. Bush and Special Advisor to Governor Schwarzenegger for Internet Communications.
David Cook is Washington bureau chief of The Christian Science Monitor and host of the Monitor's newsmaker breakfasts. He was the Monitor's editor from 1994 to 2001. Cook is a graduate of Principia College, served in the U.S. Army, was a Bagehot Fellow at Columbia University, and is a member of the Gridiron Club, Washington's oldest journalistic organization.
1. lee | 10.17.08
both funny