Politics
Politics Blog

Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez (r.) gave President Obama a book on American imperialism in Latin America at the Summit of the Americas Saturday.

(Evan Vucci/AP)

Photos (1 of 1)

Humble Obama unites Latin leaders

His cooperative tone helped some leaders begin to move beyond historical grudges against the US.

By Howard LaFranchi  |  Staff writer/ April 20, 2009 edition

Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago

A more humble approach to the region by the United States and its president this weekend helped put relations in the Americas on new and less combative footing, many of the leaders from the Summit of the Americas said Sunday.

From his arrival on Friday, President Obama sought to convince leaders of the Western Hemisphere that he brought a new approach toward a region still suspicious of US intentions. He acknowledged past US heavy-handedness, saying too often Americans “sought to dictate our terms.”

His approach was cited repeatedly over the two days of discussions, with the president of the host nation, Trinidad and Tobago, saying “what could have been derailed” by dissension was instead strengthened after Mr. Obama unveiled “a new direction by the United States.”

Obama’s posture spawned criticism in the US, however, with one Republican senator saying it was irresponsible for the president to be “laughing and joking” with Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez, whom he characterized as “one of the most anti-American leaders in the entire world.”

Fewer divisions, more work

Yet here, at an event that was Obama’s debut with Latin America, the usual divisions and posturing were replaced by a roll-up-the-sleeves spirit. The deep economic crisis facing the Western Hemisphere was certainly one reason. But so were Obama’s efforts to create a new and more equal partnership between the US and its neighbors.

“We’ve shown there are no senior or junior partners in the Americas,” Obama said at the press conference Sunday.

This approach disarmed even the most anti-American among the participants, most notably Mr. Chávez, who called former President George W. Bush a devil. Here, he gave Obama a book – albeit one about American imperialism – and told Obama, “I want to be your friend.”

Allies, too, were heartened by Obama’s demeanor and tone. Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper said Obama’s opening speech to the assembled leaders Friday germinated a new spirit that “caught on with other leaders as the summit moved on.”

US adapts to less influential role

In some respects, the new US approach simply reflects reality. While the health of the US economy remains vital to the region, the US is no longer the towering regional power it once was.

US initiatives are now rivaled by those of others in the region, especially of a rising power like Brazil. South America’s giant displayed its leadership ambitions by unveiling a loan initiative for the region’s most struggling economies – the kind of action only the US could have taken in the past.

Indeed, the gravity of the challenges facing the Americas rules out any stance but humility, some leaders said. The economy threatens to reverse a decade of falling poverty rates across the region. “No one knows with certainty how to get out of this crisis, and that reality makes everybody more humble and less arrogant,” said Brazilian President Luis Inacio Lula da Silva.

Obama’s emphasis on shared responsibility and mutual interests aims at moving US relations with the region beyond emotions – whether positive or negative, some US officials said.

“Relationships depend on more than smiles and handshakes,” White House economic adviser Lawrence Summers told reporters.

Some in Washington would prefer that the president end some of his relationships there. Sen. John Ensign (R) of Nevada told CNN: “When you’re talking about the prestige of the United States and the presidency of the United States, you have to be careful who you’re seen joking around with,” referring to Chávez. Obama, for his part, said there is much about Chávez to which he objects.

Obama touts ’soft power’

But Obama’s olive branches to America’s enemies did not end with handshakes. He indirectly praised Cuba, saying that its good image in the region results from the legions of doctors it sends to other Latin countries to tend the poor. “It’s a reminder for us in the United States that if our only interaction with many of these countries is drug interdiction, if our only interaction is military, then we may not be developing the connections that can, over time, increase our influence.”

To advance US interests, “not just here in the hemisphere but around the world,” Obama said the US must “recognize that our military power is just one arm of our power.”

But he cautioned that progress “won’t happen overnight, adding that “efforts may be strained at times because of disagreements.”

( More politics stories )

Comments

1. Dan | 04.20.09

Finally, will we see a Latin American foreign policy based on reality? Based on history? Based on morality?

Let us hope an era of justice will open up where the US will become a neighbor and not and a controller.

2. kalyan chatterjee | 04.20.09

Those who accuse President Obama of “irresponsibility” in shaking hands and joking with some of the most anti-American people are in fact the sort of people responsible for the creation of anti-American sentiment in the world. Being anti-American means being against American policy I should say, and not a wholesale condemnation of the roughly 300 million people who live in the United States. In fact there were plenty of Americans who did not agree with George Bush and his Republicans without being anti-American.
Senator John Ensign’s concern about the prestige of America calls to mind the false prestige British Imperialists stood for before circumstances forced them to wind up the empire enterprise.
As an Indian the message that I see President Obama giving is that while he is willing to reach out to erstwhile enemies, he is no pushover.

3. Chuck | 04.20.09

What summit are you talking about? The one last week had a strong anti-American feel to it. Obama did not unite anything all he did was bend over for Chávez just like he did to the Saudi king. Really, the high five thing was a little too much even for me.

4. alan macdonald | 04.20.09

Where, oh where, do guys like Chavez, Morales, and Ortega ‘get off’ with painting the US as a militarist, ‘corporate-financial Empire’ that tortures powerless people in its oil territories, and economically oppresses its own ‘working class’ citizens?

Oh, that’s right, they ‘get off’ with it because they see it directly and know the truth —- of which the American people are blinded by the ‘Vichy’ facade of democracy that this ruling-elite global ‘corporate financial Empire’ hides behind (with the help of an equally ‘Vichy’ corporate media) while the guileful EMPIRE hides in our kitchen of faux democracy and mis-uses the US super-power military to abuse the rest of the world!

There may be some method to Obama’s madness in allowing others to inform the American people about the global corporate empire in which we really live.

My bet? That not only all the other Western Hemisphere states will deliver this message today, but that all the European and other real, sustainable, and functioning ’social democracy’ (post-WWII, and post-Empire) nations of Europe and Japan will start telling America this “inconvenient truth” —- which will make Obama’s job as the reforming leader of our country more possible in bringing America from EMPIRE back to the democratic Republic that 99% of Americans thought we were and want to be again.

Alan MacDonald
Sanford, Maine

5. Byrdman | 04.20.09

This article is grossly incorrect in characterizing “the book,” Eduardo Galeano’s “Open veins of Latin America,” as one of “American imperialism.” In fact, I would encourage the author of the article to read this book before making such sweeping statements in a “news” article.

That (in)famous book, in fact, is about the exploitation of Latin American lands and people, including the exportation and exploitation of Africans, since the arrival of the Spanish and Portuguese to the continent.

Whether or not one agrees with Pres. Hugo Chavez, his gesture is quite sincere. He knows that President Obama is an author and is well read. He wants him to be familiar with Eduardo Galeano, who is one of Latin America’s most respected intellectuals.

6. George | 04.21.09

Obama “unites” Latin leaders? There’s some pro-Obama left/liberal spin for ya! Exactly whom did he unite? Accuracy would be that he cautiously spoke to Latin leaders.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

Leave a Comment

  By clicking "Submit Comment", you agree to our Terms of Service.

We do not publish all comments, and we do not publish comments immediately. The comments feature is a forum to discuss the ideas in our stories. Constructive debate - even pointed disagreement - is welcome, but personal attacks on other commenters are not, and will not be published.

Tip: Do not write a novel. Keep it short. We will not publish lengthy comments. Come up with your own statements. This is not a place to cut and paste an email you received. If we recognize it as such, we won't post it.

Please do not post any comments that are commercial in nature or that violate copyrights.

Finally, we will not publish any comments that we regard as obscene, defamatory, or intended to incite violence.